Thursday, November 20, 2014

Now Thank We All

Thanksgiving and the Psalms


November 19, 2014

         When I tried to call to mind the events of that first Thanksgiving I realized again how fuzzy my American history is!  I’m not sure whether my ignorance is a product of poor learning in the first place or loss of what I used to know.  I’m reminded of the twisted way some kids hear the Bible stories we tell.  Like the kid who listed Joan of Arc as Noah’s wife or the one who got the gist of the story about Lot’s wife right—she turned into something—but confused this story with the story of the ark of the covenant going before the people as a pillar of smoke by day and fire by night.  He suggested that Lot’s wife was “a pillar of salt” by day and a “ball of fire” by night!  I’m afraid my recollection of the events around the year 1621 in New England was just about as confused as that boy’s Bible story. 
            You see, somehow I got to thinking that the Pilgrims were the first ones to arrive in the New World, the founders of the nation.  And then I picked up on the fact that the settlers arrived down in Jamestown in 1607, thirteen years ahead of the Pilgrims at Plymouth Rock.  And next I was startled when I read about an English speaking Indian who appeared in the camp named Squanto (Tisquantum in his language).  And confused as I was by thinking that these English folks were the first ones in the area, I wondered if someone was pulling my leg about this English speaking Indian who helped the Pilgrims plant their corn and learn to catch eels.  Where did he come from?  He seemed like a Rolex watch in a cowboy movie.  But no!  My ignorance had done it to me again.  It seems that young Squanto had not only been to England but to Spain, too.  Captain John Smith of Pochohantas fame had led an expedition into the New England area years before and a fellow captain on that trip enticed some Indians on to his boats to trade furs for goods and then held them as captives.  He took them to Spain where he sold some of them as slaves before others were saved by monks in a monastery who found out what he had done.  From there Squanto made his way to England where he lived and worked for a few years, learning English along the way, before joining an expedition to Newfoundland and subsequently back to his home territory at Plymouth.  Arriving there he learned that his whole tribe had died of some disease (imported from the boat crews apparently).  It was this English speaking Squanto who was brought to the Pilgrim settlement and may have made the difference between eating and starving for them.  As is usually the case, Squanto had a darker side that emerged later but his help in that winter of 1621 was almost providential.
            That first Thanksgiving occurred sometime in the Fall of 1621, and there was food enough for the Indians and the Pilgrims alike to enjoy as they celebrated the harvest that would see them through the second winter in America.  More than half of the original settlers did not live to give thanks for that harvest.  And so , the first Thanksgiving came after tragedy, suffering and death. 
            Two and a half centuries later, October 3, 1863, President Abraham Lincoln issued the Proclamation declaring that the last Thursday in November would be Thanksgiving Day.  Our country was in the midst of a Civil War and for millions there was little for which to give thanks.  Just a month or so later the President would stand on the battlefield at Gettysburg and urge
that from these honored dead we take increased devotion to that cause for which they gave the last full measure of devotion -- that we here highly resolve that these dead shall not have died in vain -- that this nation, under God, shall have a new birth of freedom -- and that government of the people, by the people, for the people, shall not perish from the earth.
In the Thanksgiving proclamation, President Lincoln asked that we set aside the day
as a day of Thanksgiving and Praise to our beneficent Father who dwelleth in the Heavens...and fervently implore the interposition of the Almighty Hand to heal the wounds of the nation and to restore it as soon as may be consistent with the Divine purposes to the full enjoyment of peace, harmony, tranquillity and Union.
            You may be wondering about this time how all this relates to the Bible since these Wednesday presentations are supposed to be Bible Studies.  The connection (at least in my mind) lies in the close association of suffering and thanksgiving in the first Thanksgiving and in Lincoln’s proclamation.  Only because they had suffered so much could the Pilgrims rejoice so at the bounty of food that was theirs at the end of that first year.  It is very hard to appreciate that which we have never lost or come close to losing.  How often have we said or heard others say something like, “Oh, if only I had known what I had before I lost my knees (or my health or my job…)I would have done things differently!”  And of course the opposite is true too.  Those who have been granted a new lease on life or a new freedom from pain or the chance to do something they thought was lost forever are effusive in their joy and gratitude.
            This connection between thanksgiving and threats to the things we value most is not new.  In fact, it highlights something that has puzzled Old Testament scholars for a long time.  Many years ago a German scholar by the name of Hermann Gunkel wrote a book on the Psalms that changed the way scholars understand these songs.  Gunkel identified several types of Psalms and showed that all the Psalms of a certain type had the same characteristics.  You can imagine how knowing this helped scholars understand some of the psalms that been hard to interpret.  It was like giving someone a line drawing of the shape of the various states before they started putting a jigsaw puzzle together.  Now they knew what to look for.  Psalms that had been fragmentary could be pieced together with others that supplied the missing parts.
            One of the types that Gunkel identified was that of the Thanksgiving.  He said that there were two kinds of thanksgiving psalms, one used by an individual person and another that the whole community could use.   Of course we use very personal terms when as individuals we thank God for something.  Remember the chorus that we sang as teenagers:
Thank you, Lord, for saving my soul,
Thank you, Lord, for making me whole;
Thank you, Lord, for giving to me
Thy great salvation so rich and free.
And compare that with the hymn we often sing at Thanksgiving
Come, ye thankful people, come, raise the song of harvest home;
All is safely gathered in, ere the winter storms begin.
God our Maker doth provide for our wants to be supplied;
Come to God’s own temple, come, raise the song of harvest home.
One is all about “me” and the other is all about “us.”  So it was in ancient Israel too.
            There aren’t many of the communal thanksgiving psalms left in our Bible for some reason.  Since we know that there were occasions when they brought their gifts of the first fruits to the Temple, we can assume that these times would have been occasions for them to thank God for the harvest just as our Pilgrims did in 1621.  There are a few left.  One of these is Psalm 124
1] If it had not been the LORD who was on our side,
let Israel now say --
[2] if it had not been the LORD who was on our side,
when men rose up against us,
[3] then they would have swallowed us up alive,
when their anger was kindled against us;
[4] then the flood would have swept us away,
the torrent would have gone over us;
[5] then over us would have gone
the raging waters.
[6] Blessed be the LORD,
who has not given us
as prey to their teeth!
[7] We have escaped as a bird
from the snare of the fowlers;
the snare is broken,
and we have escaped!
[8] Our help is in the name of the LORD,
who made heaven and earth.
           
It is interesting that while this is a thanksgiving psalm, the word thank or thanksgiving is not used in it at all.[1] This points up something that we all know naturally there is a fine line between thanking God and praising God.  C.S. Lewis made a wonderful point when he noted that we spontaneously praise what we value and urge others to join us in praising it.  “Isn’t she lovely?  Wasn’t it glorious?  Don’t you think that magnificent?”[2]  So it is with gratitude too.
            Notice also the close association of tragedy and thankfulness in this Psalm.   Israel knew that “if the Lord had not been on our side” things would have turned out quite differently and they were thankful for that help.  While many of the Psalms praise God for his creation or for saving acts in general, the true thanksgiving psalm "was composed for some particular occasion, and offers thanks for some particular benefit experienced and bestowed on people or congregation."[3]
            When we turn to the psalms expressing the thanks of an individual this association with pain and suffering is even clearer.  In fact, expressions of thanksgiving are often actually attached to the laments that describe the tragedy.  Look at Psalm 22.  Here again the word “thanksgiving” is not in the Psalm and the gratitude is expressed as “praise.”  This is the famous Psalm which Jesus quoted on the cross.  It begins, “ My God, my God, why hast thou forsaken me and goes on to describe in exaggerated language how “all my bones are out of joint; my heart is like wax, it is melted within my breast” (v. 14).  But suddenly at verse 22, the tone changes and the Psalmist sings:
[22] I will tell of thy name to my brethren;
in the midst of the congregation I will praise thee:
[23] You who fear the LORD, praise him!
all you sons of Jacob, glorify him,
and stand in awe of him, all you sons of Israel!
[24] For he has not despised or abhorred
the affliction of the afflicted;
and he has not hid his face from him,
but has heard, when he cried to him.
[25] From thee comes my praise in the great congregation;
my vows I will pay before those who fear him.[4]
            Notice that the worshipper mentions that he had made a vow which he will now pay.  When illness or disaster struck, the worshipper would m[5] There is a beautiful (though heart-tugging) account of Hannah fulfilling the vow she made as she poured out her heart before God asking for a child.  When that child was weaned, she took him to the temple and dedicated him to God, leaving little Samuel with the priests at Shiloh in fulfillment of her vow. 
            So thanksgiving goes back a long way before 1621.  The Psalms are awfully hard to date, but clearly they were the hymns used in Solomon’s temple.  Some that are attributed to David may be even older.  Many come from the Exile (6th century B.C.) as we would expect.  Of all the tragedies that called for lamentation, the loss of Jerusalem and the shift from Israel to Babylon had to be the greatest that the nation ever faced.
            Many of the thanksgiving psalms don’t serve us well today because they focus on what God did for Israel in the Old Testament times.  A good example of this kind of thanksgiving Psalm is Psalm 105 that calls on Israel to
Give thanks to the Lord,
  call on his name,
make known his deeds among the peoples!
Sing to him, sing praises to him
  Tell of his wonderful works….
Then the psalm begins with Abraham and summarizes all the history of the Exodus and the escape from Egypt as the basis for praising the Lord.  In many ways, the story of the Exodus is the Old Testament version of the story of the Resurrection where a way out was made possible for a people completely shut in.  Understood like that, Psalm 105 still works for us Christians.
            As we approach Thanksgiving, what shall we sing?  Which liturgy shall we chant?  Though there is much hurt in our world over which to lament, there is always much for which to be thankful too.  Not least these days is the fact that there is at least one planet in this vast universe that seems to be made just for us.  Some say it is coincidence.  Most of us feel differently.  But however we understand the origin of our planet and its place in our universe, surely like the psalmist of old we should be moved to praise and thanksgiving by the fact that it is here for us.
O Lord, our Lord
            How majestic is thy name in all the earth!...
When I look at thy heavens,
            The work of thy fingers
The moon and the stars which thou has established
            What is man that thou art mindful of him
And the son of man that thou dost care for him…
O Lord, our Lord
            How majestic is thy name in all the earth!






BACK TO TEXT1. "...the Hebrew language has no word for "thank"; it uses words indicating "praise" (as a rule hodha), and "bless" berekh)...".  Sigmund Mowinckel, The Psalms in Israel's Worship, Vol 2 translated by D. R. Ap-thomas (Oxford: Basil Blackwell, 1962), 26.
BACK TO TEXT2. C. S. Lewis, Reflections on the Psalms (Collins:  Fontana Books; 1961), p 80
BACK TO TEXT3. Mowinckel, Ibid.
BACK TO TEXT4. "Might we be permitted to read Psalm 23, an individual hymn of thanksgiving, as the words of trust that are missing from the last strophe of Psalm 22? The two psalms share vocabulary and concepts, thus strengthening an argument for connecting them. Psalm 23 expresses confidence in God as shepherd to the psalmist. ...Reading Psalm 23 as a word of trust in answer to the heartfelt lament of Psalm 22 may add a new dimension of understanding to both psalms. Connecting them does not diminish the individual poetic and theological character of either, but rather creates a powerful statement of trust in the Lord."  Nancy deClaissé-Walford taken from the Working Preacher internet site:  https://www.workingpreacher.org/preaching.aspx?commentary_id=925. 
BACK TO TEXT5. Mowinckel, Op.cit., 27-28.  The thanksgiving psalm "turns to God not only to thank and praise him; it will also witness to his honour before men, and therefore turns to them.  The thanksgiving psalm will proclaim the new act of salvation, performed by [the LORD], and call upon men to honour and praise him.  The main section is therefore the tale of distress and salvation, with an introduction and a final invitation to praise and thanksgiving."

No comments:

Post a Comment